GAF Vs. Tamko: Your 2 Best Roofing Choices

Are you on the hunt for the perfect roofing material? If so, you're likely to come across two names that dominate the industry - GAF and Tamko. Both are renowned for their reliability, availability, and competitive pricing. But when it comes to choosing between the two, which one should you go for? This article aims to provide a comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision.

GAF Shingles: An Overview

GAF, the largest manufacturer of roofing materials in the U.S., has been a trusted name since 1886. Their reputation is built on quality and word-of-mouth recommendations. GAF offers three types of roofing shingles, each designed to cater to different climates and aesthetic preferences.

The 3-tab shingles from GAF are considered the industry standard, offering the best value for money. For homeowners looking to add a touch of elegance to their roofs, GAF's Timberline and Designer laminated shingles are an excellent choice, albeit at a higher price point.

Tamko Shingles: An Overview

Tamko, a family-owned business since the 1970s, is known for its reliable roofing solutions. Their Heritage line of shingles is popular for its versatility, catering to a range of architectural styles from rustic log cabins to ultra-modern homes.

Tamko shingles are available in a wider range of colors compared to other brands. They also offer a 50-year warranty on their products, covering issues like wind damage, UV fading, hail damage, and algae growth.

Durability: GAF Vs. Tamko

When it comes to durability, both GAF and Tamko offer high-quality shingles that can withstand the test of time. However, the choice between the two often comes down to the specific product lines. For instance, the GAF Timberline series is generally considered superior to the Tamko Heritage line in terms of quality and features.

Wind and Heat Protection: GAF Vs. Tamko

Wind and heat protection are critical factors in the longevity of your roof. GAF's three-tab shingles offer better wind resistance than their Tamko counterparts. However, Tamko's premium lines, the Stormfighter IR and Titan XT shingles, offer an impressive 160 mph wind warranty, one of the highest in the market.

When it comes to heat protection, both brands offer Class A heat and fire resistance based on the UL 790 standard. This means that regardless of your choice, you can rest assured that your roof will withstand the harsh summer heat.

Extra Features: GAF Vs. Tamko

When the basics are equal, the extras become the deciding factor. Both GAF and Tamko offer additional features that enhance the value of their shingles.

GAF's premium shingle lines come equipped with StainGuard Plus, an enhanced version of their anti-algae formula. This feature, coupled with a boosted warranty, adds significant value to their offerings.

On the other hand, Tamko's high-end shingle lines, like the Titan XT, feature built-in sealing strips. These strips add an extra layer of security, protecting against tear-off and improving the overall strength of the roof.

Variety: GAF Vs. Tamko

Variety is the spice of life, and this holds true for roofing shingles as well. Homeowners and designers are always on the lookout for specific styles and colors to match their vision.

In terms of color options, GAF holds a clear edge over Tamko. The Timberline series alone offers over 30 colors across five product variants. However, Tamko offers a wider variety of material choices. If standard asphalt shingles aren't your thing, Tamko also offers metal and other shingle types.

Cost and Warranty: GAF Vs. Tamko

Cost is a crucial factor when choosing between GAF and Tamko. On average, Tamko shingles tend to be cheaper than GAF shingles, except for the premium range. In terms of warranty, GAF offers one of the most comprehensive policies in the industry, especially for their premium options. You can easily find a GAF roof repair contractor. Tamko, on the other hand, offers simpler warranty terms but is generally just as effective.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, we'll address some of the most common questions homeowners have when deciding between GAF and Tamko shingles.

What is the difference between GAF and Tamko shingles?

GAF and Tamko are both reputable manufacturers of roofing shingles, but they do have some differences. GAF offers a wider range of color options, particularly in their Timberline series. They also have a more comprehensive warranty policy. Tamko, on the other hand, offers a wider variety of material choices and their premium lines, such as the Stormfighter IR and Titan XT, offer impressive wind warranties.

What is the best grade of roofing shingles?

The best grade of roofing shingles depends on your specific needs, including your budget, aesthetic preferences, and the climate in your area. However, architectural shingles, such as the GAF Timberline series or the Tamko Heritage line, are generally considered a good balance between cost and performance.

What class rating are Tamko Heritage shingles?

Tamko Heritage shingles are Class A fire-rated according to the UL 790 standard. This is the highest fire rating available for roofing materials, indicating that these shingles are highly resistant to fire.

Who makes Tamko shingles?

Tamko shingles are made by Tamko Building Products, a family-owned company that has been in the roofing business since 1944. Tamko is known for its reliable roofing solutions and offers a range of shingles to cater to different architectural styles and budgets.

Are GAF shingles better than Tamko?

Both GAF and Tamko offer high-quality shingles, and the choice between the two often comes down to personal preference. GAF shingles are generally considered superior in terms of quality and features, particularly their Timberline series. However, Tamko shingles impress with their enhanced durability, particularly in their budget and premium performance options.

How long do GAF and Tamko shingles last?

The lifespan of GAF and Tamko shingles depends on several factors, including the specific product line, the local climate, and the quality of installation. However, both brands offer products that can last for several decades. GAF's premium shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty, while Tamko offers warranty terms of 15, 30, and 50 years depending on the price bracket of the shingles.

Are Tamko shingles more expensive than GAF?

On average, Tamko shingles tend to be cheaper than GAF shingles, except in the premium range. In the premium range, Tamko's top-of-the-line Stormfighter and Titan shingles edge out their GAF equivalents in both price and performance. However, prices can vary depending on your region and the specific product line.

The Verdict

As suggested by experts who write for us on construction and real estate, choosing between GAF and Tamko often comes down to personal preference, budget, and availability. Both brands offer excellent value and reliability. While more general & roofing contractors prefer GAF for its quality, Tamko offers more versatility in terms of aesthetics. Therefore, the choice between GAF and Tamko should be based on your specific needs and preferences.

Remember, a well-informed decision is always the best decision. So, take your time, weigh your options, and choose the roofing material that best suits your needs. Happy roofing!

Other Resource: home builders, apartment guides and real estate resource